Reality Relationship TV Shows - Shaping Young Audiences' Perceptions of Relationships
- strengthofaqueen
- Mar 16
- 4 min read
Reality television has become a significant cultural phenomenon, with shows like 'Married at First Sight Australia' (MAFSA), 'Love Island,' and 'Love Is Blind' capturing the attention of millions worldwide. These programs, each with their unique formats, offer viewers a glimpse into unconventional approaches to finding love. However, they also raise questions about their influence on young audiences' perceptions of relationships. Do these shows promote healthy relationship ideals, or do they distort reality, necessitating a change in their portrayal of romance?
As a British person - I too have loved the drama of MAFSA's and prefer the Australian version to the UK version due to the level of drama and entertainment. However with the last episode of MAFSUK and the current MAFSA - it has left me with a sense of should this really be on TV and what image is it giving to it's younger viewers. Married at First Sight's appeal lies in its blend of romance and drama. The concept of marrying a stranger is both shocking and intriguing, drawing viewers eager to witness the unfolding dynamics. The show's format, combining personal storytelling with expert commentary, offers a semblance of authenticity that is meant to resonate with audiences. Over the last 3 seasons once past the wedding episodes and personal stories - fast forward to honeymoon, dinner parties and chaos ensues. 'You're not my type', gaslighting etc etc - this year's MAFSA is wilder than ever and in fact more predictable than ever.
'Love Island' places singles in a villa to couple up over weeks, and 'Love Is Blind' has participants engage without seeing each other before proposing. These varied formats provide viewers with diverse narratives that are both shocking and intriguing, drawing audiences eager to witness the unfolding dynamics and drama.
Reality TV's Impact on Relationship Perceptions
Reality television significantly influences viewers' understanding of relationships. According to cultivation theory, prolonged exposure to television content can shape individuals' perceptions of reality. When young audiences consume shows like MAFSA, 'Love Island,' and 'Love Is Blind,' they may internalize the depicted relationship norms, for better or worse.
Positive Influences
Opening Dialogue: These shows bring conversations about commitment, compatibility, and conflict resolution into the public sphere, encouraging viewers to reflect on their relationships.
Highlighting Diversity: Programs like 'Love Is Blind' feature participants from various backgrounds, promoting inclusivity and challenging traditional relationship stereotypes.
Negative Influences
Unrealistic Expectations: The dramatization of relationships can lead viewers to develop unrealistic expectations about romance and conflict, believing that intense drama is a normal aspect of relationships.
Misrepresentation of Commitment: Marrying a stranger for entertainment may trivialize the sanctity of marriage, conveying that commitment is a casual endeavour rather than a serious, lifelong decision.
Recent Controversies and Their Implications
The current seasons of these reality shows have not been without controversy, further complicating their influence on young viewers.
Participants with Prior TV Experience: Revelations that several contestants have previous reality TV or acting backgrounds have led to accusations of inauthenticity. For instance, some 'Love Island' contestants have been criticized for seeking fame over genuine connections. Such disclosures can lead viewers to question the show's authenticity, potentially fostering cynicism about genuine relationships.
Dramatic Incidents: Episodes featuring intense confrontations, such as accusations of infidelity and emotional breakdowns, contribute to a narrative that relationships are fraught with turmoil. While drama attracts viewership, it may also normalize dysfunctional behaviour as an inherent aspect of romantic relationships.
Lack of Diversity: In the Love Island UK there is an on-going debate around lack of diversity and for the few diverse contestants - they seem to always get picked last or not picked at all.
Each of these shows presents a unique approach to matchmaking and relationship building, influencing viewers differently.
'Married at First Sight Australia'
Format: Strangers are matched by experts and marry upon first meeting.
Perception Influence: The high-stakes commitment may lead viewers to question the seriousness of marriage and the feasibility of finding love in such settings.
'Love Island'
Format: Singles live in a villa, coupling up and re-coupling based on attraction and compatibility.
Perception Influence: The emphasis on physical appearance and popularity contests can skew viewers' understanding of relationship foundations, prioritizing superficial traits over deeper connections.
'Love Is Blind'
Format: Participants date and get engaged without seeing each other, focusing on emotional connections first.
Perception Influence: While promoting the idea that love transcends physical appearance, the accelerated timeline to marriage may set unrealistic expectations about the pace of relationship development.
The Debate: Entertainment vs. Responsibility
The central debate revolves around whether these reality shows serve merely as entertainment or if they hold a responsibility toward their audience, particularly younger viewers - or should they.
Entertainment Perspective
Proponents argue that these shows are designed for entertainment, offering an escape from reality. They contend that viewers are aware of the constructed nature of these programs and can distinguish between televised drama and real-life relationships.
Responsibility Perspective
Critics assert that, given their wide reach, these shows influence societal norms and individual behaviours. They believe the programs should portray healthier relationship dynamics to promote positive models for viewers, especially impressionable audiences.
The Need for Change: A Balanced Approach
Considering the potential impact on young audiences, a balanced approach in the portrayal of relationships on these shows could be beneficial.
Authentic Representation: Ensuring participants are genuinely seeking love, rather than fame, could enhance the shows' credibility and provide more realistic portrayals of relationship-building.
Educational Segments: Incorporating expert discussions on healthy relationship practices can educate viewers, offering insights beyond the drama.
Highlighting Positive Conflict Resolution: Showcasing couples navigating disagreements respectfully can model constructive behaviour for audiences.
Thorough background checks: To ensure participants have not been on other reality shows, and do not have a past of relationship abuse.
'Married at First Sight Australia,' 'Love Island,' and 'Love Is Blind' undeniably entertain and provoke thought about modern relationships. However, their influence on young viewers necessitates a careful balance between drama and responsible representation. By integrating authenticity and educational value, these programs can continue to captivate audiences while promoting healthier perceptions of relationships.
How do you think reality TV shows like 'Married at First Sight Australia,' 'Love Island,' and 'Love Is Blind' influence perceptions of relationships among young audiences? Should these programs prioritize entertainment, responsibility, or both? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Comments